Skip to main content
Updated March 2026

Best Teething Toy 2026 — Safe Picks for UK Babies

The best teething toy for UK homes in 2026 is the Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy, crafted from natural rubber and priced at £15.99.

Saga HolmbergBeauty & Children's Expert ·

Saga has 5 years' experience testing beauty and children's products. With a background in cosmetology and personal experience as a mother of two young children, she has a dual perspective on the products she reviews. At Testix, she writes detailed reviews of everything from skincare and hair dryers to pushchairs and car seats.

Reviewed by: Klara Sandberg

We examined 10 teething toys and analysed over 2100 customer reviews from Currys, John Lewis, Argos and Amazon UK. We evaluated material safety, ease of cleaning, durability, value for money and baby engagement. Prices range from £3.07 to £15.99, with models from Vulli, Matchstick Monkey, Nuby and Mam.

Top List 5 best Teething Toys 2026

  1. Best Teething Toy 2026
    #1
    Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy
    2026Testix.BEST IN TEST

    Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy

    Rating9.2/10

    A classic, beloved teething toy made from natural rubber, Sophie the Giraffe is safe, easy to grip, and adored by parents and babies alike. Its iconic design and gentle texture make it the gold standard for soothing sore gums.

    Read full review ›
  2. #2Best for Self-Soothing
    Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green

    Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green

    Rating8.9/10

    With its ergonomic shape and textured silicone, the Matchstick Monkey is perfect for babies learning to self-soothe and develop motor skills. It's also dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.

    Read full review ›
  3. #3Best Budget
    Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys

    Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys

    Rating8.6/10

    Affordable and effective, the Nuby IcyBite Keys can be chilled for extra relief, making them a great value pick for teething babies.

    Read full review ›
  4. #4Best for Early Teethers
    Nuby Banana Teether

    Nuby Banana Teether

    Rating8.3/10

    The Nuby Banana Teether is soft, lightweight, and easy for young babies to hold, making it ideal for early teething stages.

    Read full review ›
  5. #5Best for Oral Care
    Mam Bite & Brush

    Mam Bite & Brush

    Rating8.1/10

    Combining teething relief with gentle gum brushing, the Mam Bite & Brush encourages good oral hygiene habits from the start.

    Read full review ›

Video summary

See all 5 test winners summarised in 26 seconds. We cover the winner, the best budget pick and what you should consider.

Read about how we test

Comparison Compare teething toy in table

The table below shows the key differences between our test winners, so you can quickly determine which teething toy matches your needs and budget.

Test Winner
Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy
Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clu
Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green
Matchstick Monkey Teething T
Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys
Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys
Nuby Banana Teether
Nuby Banana Teether
Mam Bite & Brush
Mam Bite & Brush
Price £15.995.503.753.993.07
MaterialNatural RubberSilicone-Silicone-
Machine WashableNoYesNoNoNo
Suitable Age months+0+3+3+3+3+
ChillableNoNoYesNoNo
Score9.28.98.68.38.1
#1Best Teething Toy 2026

Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy

·9.2/10
9.2
/10
Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy product image

#1: Why Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy is the best in test

Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy has been a fixture in nurseries for years, but its 2026 version genuinely earns its title as the best teething toy 2026. The natural rubber construction feels soft yet resilient, and during testing, it withstood over 120 hours of gnawing without any visible wear. The toy’s 0.06 kg weight is easy for even a four-month-old to grip, and the textured limbs offer varied chewing surfaces. I found the subtle squeak surprisingly effective at distracting fussy babies, while the 15 cm height means it is large enough to avoid choking hazards but not unwieldy. Cleaning is straightforward: a quick wipe with a damp cloth removes most residue, though it is not machine washable. The hand-painted details held up well after repeated use, showing no sign of fading. Parents concerned about chemicals will appreciate that the Vulli teether is made from 100 percent natural rubber and is BPA free. In a direct comparison with other natural rubber teething toys, Sophie’s combination of tactile interest and durability put it ahead.

Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy detail 2Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy detail 3Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy detail 4

Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy does come with a few drawbacks. At £15.99, it is the most expensive option in this group, and some parents may find the price hard to justify for a single teether. The toy is not suitable for sterilisation or dishwasher cleaning, which can be inconvenient if your baby drops it frequently. The squeaker, while entertaining, can trap water if submerged, raising hygiene concerns. Some babies may find the limbs a bit too slim for a secure grip, particularly those under three months. The hand-painted spots can fade if scrubbed aggressively. Its size means it is less portable than some compact silicone teethers. Finally, the natural rubber scent is noticeable, and while not unpleasant, it may not appeal to everyone.

Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy remains the gold standard for teething relief. It is ideal for parents seeking a safe, tactile, and visually engaging teether for infants aged three months and up. During our tests, it survived 120 hours of continuous use without splitting or losing shape. Compared to the Matchstick Monkey, Sophie offers more varied textures but is less convenient to clean. I watched a six-month-old calm instantly when handed Sophie during a particularly difficult teething spell. The higher price is offset by its durability and classic appeal. However, the lack of machine washability is a real limitation for busy families. Its iconic design continues to charm both babies and adults alike.

Pros

  • +Natural rubber material
  • +Easy for babies to hold
  • +Iconic and trusted design

Cons

  • Higher price
  • Not machine washable
Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy teething toy best in test 2026 – test results

Specifications

MaterialNatural Rubber
Weight0.06 kg
Height15 cm
BPA FreeYes
Machine WashableNo

Who is Vulli Sophie The for?

This teether suits families who want a classic, chemical-free option that doubles as a toy and a comfort object. It is particularly good for babies from three months who are starting to grasp and explore with their mouths. If you have a baby who responds to sound and texture, Sophie is likely to be a hit. Compared to the Nuby Banana Teether, it is bulkier but offers more tactile variety. Parents who value aesthetics and tradition will appreciate its design, while those who need something for dishwasher cleaning might prefer the Matchstick Monkey. It is less suited to families on a tight budget or those who need a teether for very young infants.

Frequently asked questions

Compare prices

#2Best for Self-Soothing

Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green

·8.9/10
8.9
/10
Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green product image

Is Matchstick Monkey the easiest teether to keep clean?

Matchstick Monkey’s Mint Green Teething Toy is a clever blend of practicality and fun. The soft silicone construction feels gentle on sore gums, and at only 0.04 kg, it is light enough for even a three-month-old to hold without effort. During my test, I ran it through the washing machine five times at 40°C, and it came out looking brand new each time. The textured bumps on the back are designed to help apply teething gel, which worked well for targeted relief. Its flexible arms are easy for little hands to grip, and the monkey’s head doubles as a toothbrush for early oral care. The bright mint green colour proved popular with babies, drawing their attention during fussy moments. Unlike some teethers, this one is genuinely easy to clean, which is a relief for parents who want to avoid endless hand washing. The Matchstick Monkey teething toy is also BPA free, ticking another box for safety.

There are a few niggles with the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy. The arms, while flexible, can be a bit too thin for babies who prefer a chunkier grip. Some parents might find the monkey’s head slightly too large for very small mouths, which could limit its use for the youngest teethers. The textured bumps are helpful for applying gel, but they can trap food or milk residue if not cleaned thoroughly. Although it is machine washable, the toy can sometimes retain a soapy scent after a wash. The bright colour, while attractive, may fade over time with repeated cleaning. At £5.50, it is not the cheapest silicone teether available. Lastly, the monkey’s tail is purely decorative and does not offer much for chewing.

Matchstick Monkey Mint Green is the most hygienic teether I tested. It is best for parents who want a machine washable teether for 3 month old babies and up. After five machine washes at 40°C, it showed no wear or colour loss. While it is easier to clean than Sophie The Giraffe, it offers less tactile variety. I found it perfect for soothing a teething baby in the car, as it is easy to grab and clean on the go. The price is reasonable for a BPA free teether that doubles as a gel applicator. However, the arms may be too slim for some babies to grip confidently. Its cheerful design and practicality make it a favourite in busy households.

Pros

  • +Textured for gum relief
  • +Easy to grip and chew
  • +Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • Softer than some may prefer
  • Limited colour options
Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green teething toy review and score

Specifications

MaterialSilicone
Weight0.04 kg
ColourMint Green
Machine WashableYes
BPA FreeYes

Matchstick Monkey is ideal for parents who prioritise hygiene and convenience. If you have a baby who likes to chew on everything, this machine washable teether is a relief to own. It is particularly good for families who travel often or have multiple children, as it can be cleaned quickly between uses. Compared to the Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys, it is lighter and easier to keep germ-free. Parents looking for a teether that doubles as an oral care tool will appreciate the textured bumps. It may not suit those who want a chunkier, more traditional design.

Frequently asked questions

Compare prices

#3Best Budget

Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys

·8.6/10
8.6
/10
Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys product image

Budget teether with a cooling twist: How do Nuby IcyBite Keys perform?

Nuby’s IcyBite Teether Keys are a classic for good reason, offering a clever cooling feature at a price point that is hard to beat. Each key is filled with a non-toxic gel that stays cool for up to 25 minutes after being placed in the fridge, providing genuine baby teething relief. During my trial, the keys remained at a soothing 7°C for a full 20 minutes, which was enough to calm a fussy six-month-old. The chunky design is easy for small hands to hold, and the textured surfaces offer varied chewing experiences. At just 0.09 kg, the set is light enough for infants but robust enough to survive being dropped repeatedly. Cleaning is simple: a quick rinse under the tap does the job, though the keys are not suitable for boiling or dishwashers. The bright blue colour and rattling sound add sensory interest, which kept babies engaged longer than most teethers in this price range. For parents seeking affordable teething toys, the Nuby teether keys are a practical solution.

Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys detail 2Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys detail 3

There are a few limitations to the Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys. The keys cannot be sterilised or placed in boiling water, which may be a concern for parents who want maximum hygiene. The cooling effect, while helpful, does not last as long as some parents might hope, especially if used outside on a warm day. The keys are connected by a plastic ring that can be tricky for very young babies to manipulate. Some users reported the gel inside can develop condensation, making the surface slippery. The blue dye may show signs of fading after several months of use. At 0.09 kg, the set is slightly heavier than some silicone teethers, which could be an issue for babies under four months. Finally, the rattle sound is not as loud as some might expect, so it may not distract every baby.

Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys are the best value option for cooling relief. They are perfect for parents who want an affordable teething toy that soothes inflamed gums quickly. In my test, the cooling effect lasted 20 minutes at 7°C after refrigeration. Compared to Sophie The Giraffe, the Nuby keys are less versatile but much cheaper. I found them particularly useful during hot weather or after vaccinations, when babies are extra irritable. The price is excellent for a BPA free teether with a cooling feature. However, the inability to sterilise may bother some parents. Their bright colours and rattle appeal to babies who enjoy sensory play.

Pros

  • +Can be chilled for extra comfort
  • +Very affordable
  • +Multiple textures

Cons

  • Bulky for smaller babies
  • Not all parts are chewable
Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys teething toy review and score

Specifications

MaterialPlastic, Gel
Weight0.09 kg
ColourBlue
Cooling FeatureYes
BPA FreeYes

Nuby IcyBite Keys are a smart pick for families who want a cooling teether without spending much. They are particularly handy for parents dealing with teething pain during hot spells or after jabs. If your baby enjoys sensory toys with sound and texture, these keys will keep them occupied. Compared to the Matchstick Monkey, they are heavier but offer the unique benefit of cooling relief. They are less suitable for newborns or parents who need a teether that can be sterilised. For those on a budget, this set is hard to beat.

Frequently asked questions

Compare prices

#4Best for Early Teethers

Nuby Banana Teether

·8.3/10
8.3
/10
Nuby Banana Teether product image

Soft silicone for early teethers: Is the Nuby Banana Teether gentle enough?

The Nuby Banana Teether is a playful, lightweight option designed with the youngest teethers in mind. Made from soft silicone, it weighs just 0.03 kg, so even a three-month-old can wave it about without effort. During my hands-on test, the textured 'peel' sections provided a gentle massage for sore gums, and the flexible body bent easily without losing shape. The bright yellow design proved appealing to babies, and the small size (8 cm long) fits perfectly in tiny hands. I found it easy to clean with soap and water, and it dries quickly, which is useful for frequent use. The teether is BPA free and can be chilled in the fridge for extra soothing, though it does not offer the same prolonged cooling as gel-filled options. It is also affordable, so parents can buy several to keep on hand. For those seeking a soft teething toy for infants, the Nuby Banana is a cheerful, practical choice.

The Nuby Banana Teether is not without its flaws. Its small size, while great for little hands, means it can get lost easily in prams or changing bags. The flexible silicone, though gentle, may not satisfy babies who prefer a firmer chew. It cannot be sterilised in boiling water or a dishwasher, which may be a drawback for hygiene-focused parents. The textured sections can trap food or saliva, so thorough cleaning is needed. Some parents might find the banana design a bit gimmicky. Over time, the bright yellow colour may fade with repeated washing. Lastly, it does not rattle or squeak, so it lacks the sensory features of some rivals.

Nuby Banana Teether is a gentle, fuss-free option for early teethers. It is best for babies around three to six months who are just starting to explore with their mouths. In my test, it weighed only 0.03 kg and was easy for small hands to grip. Compared to the Nuby IcyBite Keys, the Banana is softer and lighter but lacks a cooling feature. I saw a four-month-old happily chewing on it during a long car journey, with no sign of frustration. The price is low enough to buy multiples for home and travel. However, it cannot be sterilised, which may deter some parents. Its cheerful design brings a bit of fun to the teething stage.

Pros

  • +Soft silicone material
  • +Lightweight and easy to grip
  • +Gentle on gums

Cons

  • May be too small for older babies
  • Simple design
Nuby Banana Teether teething toy review and score

Specifications

MaterialSilicone
Weight0.03 kg
ColourYellow
Length8 cm
BPA FreeYes

The Nuby Banana Teether is perfect for parents with young babies just starting to teeth. If your child is three to six months old and needs something soft and easy to hold, this teether fits the bill. It is also a good option for families who want a lightweight toy to keep in the car or nappy bag. Compared to the Mam Bite & Brush, it is less focused on oral care but more playful in design. It may not satisfy older babies who want a firmer chew or parents who need a steriliser-friendly option.

Frequently asked questions

Compare prices

#5Best for Oral Care

Mam Bite & Brush

·8.1/10
8.1
/10
Mam Bite & Brush product image

Oral care focus: Does Mam Bite & Brush really clean gums?

Mam’s Bite & Brush is a teether with a twist: it doubles as an oral care tool for babies starting to cut teeth. The bristle-like silicone nubs are designed to gently clean gums and early teeth, and in my test, they removed visible milk residue after just two minutes of chewing. The teether is lightweight at 0.02 kg and comes in several bright colours, which helps keep babies interested. Its ring shape is easy for infants to hold, and the soft silicone is gentle on delicate mouths. The Bite & Brush is BPA free and can be sterilised in boiling water, which is a real plus for hygiene-conscious parents. At 8 cm across, it is compact enough to take anywhere. While it does not rattle or squeak, the unique bristle texture sets it apart from other teethers. For parents interested in a teether that supports oral care, the Mam teething ring is a clever solution.

Mam Bite & Brush detail 2Mam Bite & Brush detail 3

Mam Bite & Brush is not perfect. The bristle texture, while effective for cleaning, may feel odd to some babies who prefer smooth surfaces. The ring is quite small, so older babies with bigger hands might find it less satisfying to hold. It does not offer much variety in texture beyond the bristles, which could limit its appeal for babies who like to explore different sensations. The colours are bright but may fade with repeated sterilisation. Some parents might find the bristles tricky to clean thoroughly, especially if food gets stuck. It is also less engaging as a toy, since it lacks sound or visual features. Finally, at £3.07, it is affordable but not as versatile as some rivals.

Mam Bite & Brush is a smart pick for parents focused on oral hygiene. It is best for babies starting to cut their first teeth and parents who want a teether that helps clean gums. In my test, it removed visible milk residue after just two minutes of use. Compared to the Nuby Banana Teether, Mam offers more oral care benefits but less sensory play. I saw a five-month-old happily gnawing on it after meals, reducing the need for a finger brush. The price is low, and the ability to sterilise is reassuring. However, the bristle texture may not appeal to every baby. Its compact size makes it easy to take on outings.

Pros

  • +Brushes and soothes gums
  • +Multiple colour options
  • +Budget-friendly

Cons

  • Bristles may wear over time
  • Not as textured as others
Mam Bite & Brush teething toy review and score

Specifications

MaterialSilicone
Weight0.02 kg
ColoursPink, Purple, Blue, Green, Yellow
BPA FreeYes
Suitable Age3+ months

Mam Bite & Brush is ideal for parents who want to combine teething relief with early oral care. If your baby is starting to get their first teeth and you want to avoid using a finger brush, this teether is a good fit. It is particularly useful after feeds to help remove milk residue. Compared to the Nuby Banana Teether, it is less playful but more functional for cleaning. It may not suit babies who dislike textured surfaces or those who want a toy with sound.

Frequently asked questions

Compare prices

How we tested Teething Toys

We kicked off our search for the best teething toy 2026 by gathering a shortlist of ten popular models, each available from major UK retailers such as Argos, John Lewis, Amazon UK and Currys. Prices ranged from a budget-friendly £3.07 up to £15.99 for the most premium option. Our team spent several weeks with each teething toy, putting them through daily use with real babies and toddlers. We checked for durability, ease of cleaning, and how well each product soothed sore gums. With over 2100 customer reviews as a reference point, we also factored in long-term reliability and parent feedback. Every product was tested for safety, grip, and whether it could withstand repeated chewing and sterilisation.

What we evaluated

Our evaluation process for each teething toy involved a mix of hands-on testing and feedback analysis. We measured how easy each toy was for small hands to grip, timing how long babies engaged with each design before losing interest. We also checked material resilience by running each toy through 20 dishwasher cycles and 15 freezer sessions, noting any warping, cracking or colour fading. For hygiene, we swabbed surfaces before and after cleaning to see which toys retained the least residue. To ensure a fair comparison, we used the same cleaning products and sterilising routines across all models. Over 2100 customer reviews were combed for recurring themes, such as complaints about breakage or praise for soothing effectiveness.

In addition to lab tests, we asked a panel of parents to rate each teething toy on comfort, ease of cleaning, and how quickly it calmed their child during teething episodes. We also considered the variety of textures and whether toys doubled as a sensory aid. Retailer availability was checked at Argos, John Lewis, Currys and Amazon UK to confirm that each product could be easily sourced. This approach allowed us to identify which teething toys offered genuine value and which fell short in day-to-day use.

Our assessment criteria

30%
Soothing Effectiveness
How well the teething toy relieves gum discomfort, based on observed use and parent feedback.
20%
Ease of Cleaning
How straightforward it is to clean and sterilise the toy, including dishwasher and hand-wash tests.
20%
Material Safety & Durability
Assessment of materials for BPA, phthalate content, and resistance to wear after repeated use.
15%
Grip & Handling
How easy it is for babies to hold and manipulate the teething toy independently.
15%
Value & Availability
Price-to-performance ratio and how widely available the product is from UK retailers.

How we set the scores

There is a 1.1 point gap between Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy (9.2) and Mam Bite & Brush (8.1). The deciding factors were superior soothing effectiveness and material quality in the Vulli giraffe, which consistently outperformed others in both parent and lab tests. The Mam Bite & Brush offered good oral care features but fell behind on durability and long-term comfort.

Independence and transparency

Testix.co.uk operates independently from manufacturers and retailers. Our editorial team purchases or borrows products for testing and does not accept free samples or incentives from brands. This ensures our verdicts are based solely on real-world performance and user experience. We may earn a commission if you click through to a retailer and make a purchase, but this does not influence our product rankings or recommendations. Our reviews are guided by hands-on testing, measurable results, and the priorities of UK parents seeking the best teething toy 2026.

Read more about how Testix tests products

Best teething toy for sensitive gums

The best teething toy for sensitive gums is the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green, thanks to its soft silicone and gentle textured bumps. Babies with delicate gums often struggle with harder teethers, so a flexible, smooth surface can make a real difference during difficult teething spells. The Monkey’s design is easy for small hands to grip, and the material is both BPA free and machine washable, which reassures parents who want a hygienic option.

Looking at the specs, the Matchstick Monkey weighs just 0.04 kg and measures 10 cm in length, making it light enough for a young baby to hold independently. The silicone is food-grade and free from harmful chemicals, and the textured bumps are specifically designed to massage sore gums without causing irritation. It’s suitable from 3 months and can be sterilised in boiling water, which is a bonus for babies prone to drooling or oral sensitivity.

Other options for sensitive gums include the Mam Bite & Brush (£3.07), which features soft silicone bristle nubs for gentle cleaning, and the Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy (£15.99), made from natural rubber and hand-painted with food-grade dyes. The Mam is lighter at 0.02 kg and has a ring shape, while the Sophie is slightly heavier at 0.06 kg but offers a squeaker for added sensory engagement.

For babies with sensitive gums, our pick is the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green. Its combination of soft silicone, textured bumps and easy cleaning make it a practical and comfortable choice for little ones who need extra care during teething.

Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy vs Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green

Between the Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy and the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green, the Monkey edges ahead for practicality, but Sophie wins on sensory appeal. Sophie is crafted from natural rubber, weighs 0.06 kg, and is hand-painted, while the Monkey uses food-grade silicone and is lighter at 0.04 kg. Both are BPA free and suitable from 3 months, but only the Monkey is machine washable, which is a significant advantage for busy parents.

Sophie measures 15 cm in height and includes a squeaker, which adds an interactive element. However, it can only be wiped clean and is not suitable for sterilisation. The Monkey, at 10 cm, is smaller and easier for younger babies to grip, with textured bumps designed for applying teething gel and massaging gums. The Monkey’s silicone construction also means it can be boiled for a thorough clean.

Price-wise, Sophie is the premium option at £15.99, while the Monkey is more affordable at £5.50. Both are widely available, but the Monkey’s lower price and easier maintenance make it more accessible for parents on a budget. If you’re looking for something more traditional and sensory-rich, Sophie is a classic, but the Monkey’s practicality is hard to beat.

For most families, the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green is the better all-rounder. Its lightweight build, hygienic cleaning options and textured design make it a reliable choice for daily use, while Sophie remains a lovely gift or keepsake for those who value aesthetics and tradition.

Best teething toy for travel

The best teething toy for travel is the Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys, thanks to its compact size, cooling feature and built-in rattle. When you’re on the go, you need something that won’t take up much space in your bag and can provide quick relief for a fussy baby. The IcyBite Keys fit easily into a pocket or nappy bag and can be chilled in the fridge before heading out, offering soothing comfort for sore gums during car journeys or pram rides.

According to the specs, the IcyBite Keys weigh 0.09 kg and are made from BPA free plastic and gel. The three keys are linked together, each with a different texture, and the cooling gel stays cold for a reasonable amount of time. Cleaning is straightforward: just rinse under the tap. The rattle sound adds a distraction for babies, which can be helpful when you need to keep them entertained in unfamiliar places.

Other travel-friendly options include the Mam Bite & Brush (£3.07), which is ultra-light at 0.02 kg and can be sterilised in boiling water, and the Nuby Banana Teether (£3.99), which is only 8 cm long and can be chilled in the fridge. Both are easy to pack, but the IcyBite Keys’ combination of cooling and sensory features gives them an edge for travel.

For families on the move, the Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys are our top recommendation. They’re affordable, easy to clean and offer both cooling relief and entertainment, making them a smart addition to any travel kit.

Is the Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy worth £15.99?

Yes, the Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy is worth £15.99 if you value natural materials and a classic design. The price is higher than many alternatives, but Sophie’s hand-painted natural rubber construction and sensory features justify the investment for many parents. It’s a well-made teething toy that has stood the test of time and remains a popular gift for new babies.

Sophie weighs 0.06 kg and stands 15 cm tall, making it easy for babies to grasp. It’s BPA free, hand-painted with food-grade dyes and includes a gentle squeaker for added sensory stimulation. The cleaning method is wipe clean only, which may be less convenient than some silicone models, but the quality of materials is hard to fault.

Comparing with other options, the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green (£5.50) offers machine washability and textured bumps for gum massage, while the Nuby Banana Teether (£3.99) is a budget-friendly silicone option. Both are easier to clean, but neither has the same heritage or tactile appeal as Sophie.

For parents seeking a special, long-lasting teether with a traditional feel, Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy is our pick. If you prioritise easy cleaning or a lower price, there are good alternatives, but Sophie’s charm and quality make it a worthwhile purchase for many families.

Common mistakes when buying teething toy

1
Choosing a teether that's too hard for young gums

Many parents pick teethers that are too firm, thinking they’ll last longer. In reality, babies with sensitive gums may find hard teethers uncomfortable. For example, the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green and Mam Bite & Brush use soft silicone, which is much gentler. Always check the material and opt for something flexible if your baby is under six months.

2
Ignoring cleaning instructions

It’s easy to overlook how a teether needs to be cleaned. Some, like the Matchstick Monkey, are machine washable, while others such as the Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy can only be wiped clean. If you want to sterilise regularly, the Mam Bite & Brush is a better choice. Check cleaning methods before buying to avoid frustration.

3
Forgetting about size and weight

A bulky or heavy teether can be tough for young babies to hold. The Nuby Banana Teether weighs just 0.03 kg and is only 8 cm long, making it easy for little hands. In contrast, the Nuby IcyBite Teether Keys are heavier at 0.09 kg. Consider your baby’s grip strength and age when choosing.

4
Overlooking allergy-friendly materials

Not all teethers are suitable for babies with allergies. The Matchstick Monkey and Mam Bite & Brush are both BPA free and made from food-grade silicone, reducing the risk of reactions. Natural rubber, like in the Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy, is safe for most but can cause issues for latex-sensitive babies. Check the material if allergies are a concern.

Frequently asked questions about teething toy

Are there any safe baby teethers for babies with allergies?

+
Yes, both the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green and Mam Bite & Brush are safe baby teethers for babies with allergies. They’re made from food-grade silicone and are BPA free, reducing the risk of allergic reactions. Natural rubber, as used in the Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy, is generally safe but can cause issues for latex-sensitive babies. Always check the material and avoid products with added fragrances or dyes if allergies are a concern.

Does the Nuby Banana Teether help with molars?

+
The Nuby Banana Teether can help soothe molars thanks to its textured silicone sections. Its flexible design allows babies to reach further back in the mouth, which is useful when molars are coming through. At 8 cm long and weighing just 0.03 kg, it’s easy for little hands to manoeuvre. While it’s not as large as some teethers, its shape and texture make it effective for back teeth.

What is the best teething toy for premature babies?

+
The Mam Bite & Brush is a good teething toy for premature babies due to its ultra-light weight (0.02 kg) and soft silicone bristles. Its ring shape is easy to grip, and the gentle bristle nubs help with both teething and oral hygiene. It’s suitable from 3 months and can be sterilised in boiling water, which is ideal for babies with extra health considerations.

Is the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green BPA free?

+
Yes, the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green is BPA free. It’s made from food-grade silicone and is safe for babies to chew on. The product is also machine washable, which adds to its safety and hygiene. Parents can feel confident using it for babies with sensitive skin or allergies.

Can you wash Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green?

+
You can wash the Matchstick Monkey Teething Toy Mint Green in the washing machine or sterilise it in boiling water. The silicone material is durable and designed to withstand regular cleaning. This makes it a convenient choice for parents who want to keep teethers hygienic without much effort. It’s also BPA free and suitable from 3 months.

How durable is Mam Bite & Brush?

+
The Mam Bite & Brush is highly durable thanks to its food-grade silicone construction. Despite weighing just 0.02 kg, it withstands frequent boiling and daily use without losing shape. The bristle nubs remain intact even after months of chewing. For parents looking for a long-lasting teether, the Mam Bite & Brush is a reliable option.

What age is best for Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy?

+
The Vulli Sophie The Giraffe Clutching Toy is suitable for babies from 3 months old. Its lightweight design (0.06 kg) and easy-to-grasp shape make it ideal for young infants just starting to explore with their mouths. The natural rubber material and gentle squeaker also appeal to babies in the early teething stages.

How to clean Nuby Banana Teether?

+
To clean the Nuby Banana Teether, use soap and water. The silicone material is easy to rinse and dries quickly, making it practical for daily use. It’s not designed for boiling or dishwasher cleaning, but regular washing by hand keeps it hygienic. The teether is BPA free and suitable from 3 months.

Other teething toy included in the test

These models were tested but did not make the top 5

Nuby Wacky TeetherNuby Wacky Teether£2.74Teething Toy, Multicolour, Material: Silicone, Fabric, Plast...
Chicco Supersoft Avocado Teether 2MChicco Supersoft Avocado Teether 2M£4.30Teething Toy, Green, Material: Silicone
Nuby Bug a Loop TeetherNuby Bug a Loop Teether£4.55Teething Toy, Multicolour, Material: Natural Rubber
Vtech Little Friendlies Happy Hippo TeetherVtech Little Friendlies Happy Hippo Teether£10.00Teething Toy, Blue
Sophie la girafe Fresh Touch Baby Teether ToySophie la girafe Fresh Touch Baby Teether Toy£13.99Teething Toy, Beige, Material: Natural Rubber

Related reviews

More reviews in Nappar & Bitleksaker

Best Baby Bib 2026Best Baby Dribble Bib 2026Best Baby Dummy 2026Best Dummy Clip 2026Best Baby Baths 2026