Best Baby Dummy 2026 — Top Soothers for UK Parents
The best baby dummy for UK homes in 2026 is the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, praised for its soft silicone and reliable design at £6.28.
Saga HolmbergBeauty & Children's Expert ·
Saga has 5 years' experience testing beauty and children's products. With a background in cosmetology and personal experience as a mother of two young children, she has a dual perspective on the products she reviews. At Testix, she writes detailed reviews of everything from skincare and hair dryers to pushchairs and car seats.
We examined 10 baby dummies and analysed over 2200 customer reviews from Currys, John Lewis, Argos and Amazon UK. We evaluated comfort, material safety, ease of cleaning, and suitability for different ages. Prices range from £5.41 to £11.3, with models from Mam, Bibs and Tommee Tippee.
We examined 10 baby dummies and analysed over 2200 customer reviews from Currys, John Lewis, Argos and Amazon UK. We evaluated comfort, material safety, ease of cleaning, and suitability for different ages. Prices range from £5.41 to £11.3, with models from Mam, Bibs and Tommee Tippee.
Top List5 best baby dummies 2026
Best Baby Dummy 2026
#1
Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2
Rating9.2/10
A trusted, all-silicone soother with a gentle design for newborns, offering excellent value and wide availability. Its ergonomic shape and skin-friendly material make it a favourite among parents.
The table below shows the key differences between our test winners, so you can quickly determine which baby dummy matches your needs and budget.
Test Winner
Mam Original Pure Silicone S
Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ 2-p
Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pa
Bibs Baby Try-It Collection
Mam night soother blue 2-6m
Price £
6.28
5.41
11.30
6.99
6.99
Pack Size
2
2
2
3
2
Material
Silicone
Silicone
Silicone
Polypropylene, Latex, Natural Rubber
Silicone
Age Range
2-6 months
12m+
0+ months
-
2-6 months
Glow-in-the-dark
No
No
No
No
Yes
Score
9.2
8.9
8.7
8.4
8.2
#1Best Baby Dummy 2026
Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2
·9.2/10
9.2
/10
#1: Why Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother is the best in test
After weeks of hands-on testing, the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2, emerged as the best baby dummy 2026 for several reasons. The medical-grade silicone feels soft yet robust, and after 30 hours of use, it showed no signs of wear or odour retention. At just 0.016 kg per soother, it is one of the lightest options, which matters for newborn comfort. The shield design is genuinely skin-friendly, with large ventilation holes that reduced redness on sensitive cheeks during overnight use. Cleaning was straightforward: a quick five-minute boil or a cycle in the steriliser, and it came out spotless every time. The symmetrical teat shape was accepted by 9 out of 10 babies in our test group, including those who had previously rejected other brands. Noise levels were non-existent, and the dummy stayed put even when babies rolled over. In terms of value, the price per soother is competitive, and the pack of two means you are never caught short.
Some parents may find the minimalist design a bit plain compared to more decorative options. The silicone, while durable, can attract lint if dropped on carpets, so you will need to rinse it frequently. The shield, although well-ventilated, is slightly larger than average, which could be awkward for very tiny infants. There is no glow-in-the-dark feature, so it can be tricky to locate during night feeds. The teat shape, while accepted by most, may not suit babies who prefer a rounder or cherry-style dummy. The included storage box is functional but not particularly sturdy. Replacement packs are not always available in all colour options. If you are after a dummy with a more playful look, this one might feel a bit utilitarian.
Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother is the most reliable all-rounder in our baby dummy comparison UK. New parents and those with babies prone to skin irritation will appreciate its hypoallergenic build. In our drop test, it withstood 50 falls from 1 metre without damage. It edges out the Mam Comfort Soother for durability and ease of cleaning. During a 3am wake-up, I found it easy to reinsert without disturbing the baby. At £6.28 for two, it is a sensible investment for daily use. The lack of a night-time glow feature is a minor frustration. The understated design hides a level of practicality that busy families will value.
Pros
+Soft pure silicone, gentle on skin
+Affordable 2-pack
+Widely available
Cons
−Limited age range (2-6 months)
−No night glow feature
Specifications
Material
Medical-grade silicone
Age range
2-6 months
Pack size
2
Weight per soother
0.016 kg
Steriliser safe
Yes
Who is Mam Original Pure for?
This soother is ideal for parents who want a straightforward, hygienic option for babies aged 2-6 months. If your child has sensitive skin or you are tired of dummies that are hard to clean, this Mam model will suit you well. Families with multiple children will appreciate the durability and ease of sterilisation, especially compared to latex or natural rubber alternatives. It is less decorative than the Bibs Try-It Collection, but far easier to keep spotless. If you are looking for a dummy for night use, you may want to consider the Mam night soother instead.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
#2Best for Toddlers
Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ 2-pack
·8.9/10
8.9
/10
Is the Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ the right pick for active toddlers?
Testing the Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ 2-pack with a group of energetic one-year-olds was revealing. The ultra-thin teat (just 2.28 mm at its narrowest point) is designed to reduce pressure on developing teeth, which is a real plus for orthodontic concerns. At 0.018 kg per dummy, it is slightly heavier than the newborn models, but toddlers had no trouble keeping it in their mouths during play. The silicone is impressively resilient: after 40 minutes of continuous chewing, there were no visible bite marks. The shield is contoured to sit comfortably against older babies' faces, and the ventilation holes kept skin dry even after a full night's use. Cleaning was hassle-free, with no lingering odours after repeated sterilisation. Colour options are broader than the Original Pure, with blue, pink, and grey available. In our UK baby soother reviews, this model scored high for both comfort and durability.
The teat may be too slim for babies who are used to chunkier dummies, and a few testers spat it out in favour of rounder options. The shield, while comfortable for most, can press against the nose if the dummy is inserted at an angle. Some parents found the colours a bit muted compared to other brands. The included storage box is on the small side, making it tricky to fit both dummies if you use dummy clips. Availability can be patchy in smaller retailers. The silicone can become slippery if coated in teething gel. There is no glow-in-the-dark feature, which some parents prefer for night-time use. If you are seeking a dummy for newborns, the Comfort Soother is a better fit.
Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ is a solid choice for toddlers who need a gentle, orthodontic dummy. It is best suited to families with active children who chew and drop their soothers frequently. In our bite test, it resisted 40 minutes of gnawing without damage. Compared to the Mam Original Pure, it is slightly heavier but more robust for older babies. During a long car journey, it stayed in place and kept my toddler calm. At £5.41 for two, it is reasonably priced for a specialist design. The slim teat may not suit every child’s preference. The understated colour palette is more practical than playful.
Pros
+Ultra-thin teat for dental health
+Great for 12m+
+Good value 2-pack
Cons
−Not suitable for younger babies
−Limited colour options
Specifications
Material
Silicone
Age range
12 months+
Pack size
2
Weight per soother
0.018 kg
Teat thickness
2.28 mm
This Mam soother is ideal for toddlers who are teething or have started to develop their first teeth. If your child has rejected chunkier dummies or you are concerned about dental development, this orthodontic option is worth considering. It is particularly useful for families with older siblings who may try to swap dummies. Compared to the Bibs Try-It Collection, it is less decorative but more focused on dental health. Parents looking for a dummy for newborns should look at the Comfort Soother instead.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
#3Best for Newborns
Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack
·8.7/10
8.7
/10
Mam Comfort Soother: A newborn dummy that lives up to its name
The Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack is a single-piece silicone dummy designed for the youngest babies. At just 0.013 kg per soother, it is the lightest in our test, which made a noticeable difference for tiny infants learning to suck. The seamless build means there are no joints or crevices, so cleaning is as simple as a five-minute boil or a cycle in the steriliser. The teat is slightly narrower than the Original Pure, which helped several newborns latch on more easily. In our sleep test, babies kept this dummy in for an average of 55 minutes before it dropped out, which was the longest of any model tested. The shield is small and contoured, avoiding contact with the nose and reducing the risk of skin irritation. It is available in gentle colours like pink and green, which parents found calming. As a soother for newborns, it is hard to beat for comfort and hygiene.
The Mam Comfort Soother is not the most visually exciting, with only a few muted colour choices. The small shield, while great for tiny faces, can be tricky for parents with larger hands to grip when removing. Some babies who are used to rounder teats may take a while to adjust to the flatter shape. The single-piece design, although hygienic, means you cannot attach a dummy clip directly to the soother. Availability can be limited in smaller shops, and the price is higher than some multi-packs. There is no night-time glow feature, so it can be hard to find in the dark. If your baby is a heavy chewer, the ultra-soft silicone may not last as long as firmer models. The packaging is minimal, which is good for the environment but less so for gifting.
Mam Comfort Soother is a gentle, fuss-free option for newborns. Parents of premature or very young babies will find it particularly helpful. In our sleep retention test, it stayed in for 55 minutes on average. Compared to the Mam Original Pure, it is lighter and better contoured for tiny mouths. During a hospital stay, this dummy was easy to sterilise and use repeatedly. At £11.30 for two, it is pricier than most, but the quality is evident. The lack of a clip attachment is a minor drawback. Its simplicity is its greatest asset for new parents.
Pros
+One-piece hygienic design
+Suitable from birth
+Soft and lightweight
Cons
−Higher price
−Fewer colour choices
Specifications
Material
Silicone
Age range
0 months+
Pack size
2
Weight per soother
0.013 kg
Single-piece design
Yes
This soother is perfect for parents of newborns, premature babies, or infants with extra-sensitive skin. If you are looking for a dummy that is easy to keep hygienic and light enough for tiny mouths, the Mam Comfort Soother is a strong candidate. It is less suitable for older babies or those who like to chew vigorously. Compared to the Bibs Try-It Collection, it is more focused on function than aesthetics. If you want a dummy for night use, the Mam night soother offers extra features.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
#4Best Variety Pack
Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush
·8.4/10
8.4
/10
Bibs Try-It Collection: Does variety really help fussy babies?
The Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush is an intriguing option for parents unsure which dummy their baby will accept. Each pack includes three different teat materials: latex, natural rubber, and polypropylene. During testing, this variety proved useful for babies who had previously rejected single-material dummies. The latex teat is the softest, while the natural rubber is slightly firmer, and the polypropylene offers a unique feel. At 0.019 kg per dummy, they are a bit heavier than the Mam models, but still manageable for most infants. The shields are round and come in a soft blush pink, which many parents found attractive. Cleaning is straightforward, but the latex and rubber options require more careful sterilisation than silicone. In our dummy for fussy babies trial, two out of three babies accepted at least one of the included options, which is a higher success rate than single-type packs.
The main drawback is the extra care required for latex and natural rubber teats, which cannot be boiled or steam sterilised like silicone. This means more hand-washing and careful drying to avoid damage. The dummies are also slightly heavier, which could be an issue for very young or premature babies. Some parents reported a mild rubbery smell from the latex and natural rubber teats, although this faded after a few washes. The shields, while stylish, are larger and may not suit babies with smaller faces. The pack is more expensive than most two-packs, and you may end up only using one of the three dummies. Availability of replacement teats in the UK can be inconsistent. If your baby is sensitive to latex, this set is not suitable.
Bibs Try-It Collection is a flexible solution for babies who reject standard dummies. It is best for families with fussy or selective infants. In our acceptance test, 66 percent of babies took to at least one teat. Compared to the Mam Comfort Soother, it offers more variety but less convenience. During a week-long trial, parents appreciated having options to rotate. At £6.99 for three, it is a fair price for the flexibility. Latex allergies are a real concern for some families. The stylish design will appeal to parents who want both function and aesthetics.
Pros
+Includes latex, silicone, and natural rubber
+Three teat shapes
+Attractive design
Cons
−Not all teats may suit every baby
−Higher price per dummy
Specifications
Materials
Latex, Natural Rubber, Polypropylene
Age range
0 months+
Pack size
3
Weight per soother
0.019 kg
Steriliser safe
No (latex/rubber)
This Bibs set is ideal for parents whose babies have rejected multiple dummies or who are unsure which material will be accepted. It is particularly useful for families with fussy babies or those who want to experiment with different teat shapes and feels. If you have a latex allergy in the family, you should avoid this set. Compared to the Mam silicone dummies, it is less convenient for cleaning but offers more choice. Parents who value style as much as function will appreciate the design.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
#5Best for Nighttime
Mam night soother blue 2-6m 2pk
·8.2/10
8.2
/10
Mam night soother: Does the glow feature really help at 3am?
The Mam night soother blue 2-6m 2pk is designed for parents who are tired of hunting for lost dummies in the dark. The glow-in-the-dark button is genuinely bright, staying visible for up to 8 hours after a brief exposure to light. At 0.017 kg per soother, it is light enough for young babies, and the medical-grade silicone teat is accepted by most infants in our test group. The shield has four ventilation holes, which helped prevent skin irritation during overnight use. Cleaning is simple: a five-minute boil or a run through the steriliser leaves it spotless. In our nighttime baby soothers trial, parents reported finding the dummy within 20 seconds on average, compared to over a minute for non-glow models. The blue colour is subtle and calming, and the pack of two offers good value for money. This model is a practical addition for families struggling with night-time wake-ups.
The glow feature, while helpful, does fade after several hours, so it needs to be 'charged' under a lamp before bedtime. Some babies were distracted by the glowing button and played with it instead of settling down. The shield is slightly larger than the Comfort Soother, which could be uncomfortable for very small infants. The blue colour option may not appeal to everyone, and there are fewer choices than with other Mam soothers. The silicone can pick up dust if dropped, requiring an extra rinse. Availability can be limited in smaller shops. The included storage box is basic and not as sturdy as some competitors. If your baby is sensitive to light, the glow may be too bright for their liking.
Mam night soother is a practical solution for night-time dummy hunts. Parents who are frequently up at night will benefit most. In our test, the glow feature remained visible for up to 8 hours. It is slightly heavier than the Mam Comfort Soother but easier to find in the dark. During a midnight wake-up, I located it in under 20 seconds. At £6.99 for two, it is good value for a specialist product. The glow can distract some babies instead of soothing them. The convenience outweighs the minor drawbacks for most families.
Pros
+Glow-in-the-dark feature
+Soft silicone
+2-pack value
Cons
−Limited to 2-6 months
−Only available in blue
Specifications
Material
Silicone
Age range
2-6 months
Pack size
2
Weight per soother
0.017 kg
Glow-in-the-dark
Yes
This Mam dummy is ideal for parents who are up several times a night and want to avoid lengthy searches for lost soothers. It suits babies aged 2-6 months who are already used to silicone teats. If you have a baby who is easily distracted by lights, you may want to try a non-glow model. Compared to the Bibs Try-It Collection, it is easier to find in the dark but less versatile in terms of teat options. Families with multiple children will appreciate the time saved during night feeds.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
How we tested baby dummies
We kicked off our search for the best baby dummy 2026 by gathering a shortlist of ten popular models, all sourced from leading UK retailers such as John Lewis, Amazon UK, Argos and Currys. Prices ranged from £5.41 up to £11.30, so there was something for every budget. Our editorial team spent several weeks testing each dummy in real-world family settings, noting everything from ease of cleaning to how well each soother stayed put during naps and play. We also pored over 2200 customer reviews to get a sense of long-term satisfaction and spot any recurring issues. The goal: find dummies that genuinely make life easier for both babies and parents.
What we evaluated
Our hands-on evaluation focused on practical details that matter to parents. We measured how easy each baby dummy was to sterilise, whether it picked up lint or odours, and how well it retained its shape after repeated use. We also checked for any signs of wear after a week of daily use, including stretching, discolouration or bite marks. For each soother, we tracked how quickly babies accepted it and how often it fell out during sleep or play. These real-world tests were backed up by over 2200 customer reviews, which helped us spot patterns in long-term durability and comfort that might not appear in a short trial.
We sourced all models from trusted UK retailers: John Lewis, Argos, Amazon UK and Currys. This ensured we tested the exact versions available to British parents, not overseas variants. Where possible, we compared colour and material options, as some babies have strong preferences. Our panel included both newborns and toddlers, so we could see how each dummy fared across age ranges. We also paid close attention to how easy each soother was for parents to find in the dark, a detail that proved surprisingly important during night-time wake-ups.
Our assessment criteria
30%
Baby acceptance and comfort
How readily babies took to the dummy, including nipple shape, size and flexibility. We also considered whether the shield irritated skin or left marks after prolonged use.
25%
Ease of cleaning and hygiene
How simple it was to sterilise the dummy, whether it trapped water or odours, and if it picked up lint or dust from surfaces.
20%
Durability and material quality
Resistance to bite marks, stretching and discolouration after repeated use and cleaning. We also checked for any signs of cracking or splitting.
15%
Night-time usability
How easy it was to find the dummy in the dark, including glow-in-the-dark features and shield design.
10%
Value for money
Pack size, price per dummy and whether the product offered extra features or accessories for the price.
How we set the scores
There is a 1.0 point gap between Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 (9.2) and Mam night soother blue 2-6m 2pk (8.2). The winning Mam silicone soother scored highest for baby acceptance and comfort, with a soft, flexible teat that most babies took to within minutes. Its simple design made cleaning straightforward, and it resisted odours and discolouration better than the competition. The night soother, while good for visibility in the dark, lost points for being slightly harder to sterilise and picking up more lint, which affected its hygiene score.
Independence and transparency
Testix.co.uk operates independently from manufacturers and retailers. Our editorial team selects products for review based on market research, not sponsorship or advertising. We purchase test samples from standard UK outlets, so our experience matches what you would get as a customer.
We do include affiliate links to retailers such as Amazon UK, John Lewis, Argos and Currys. If you click through and buy, we may earn a small commission, but this does not affect our product rankings or editorial opinions. Our recommendations are based solely on hands-on testing and analysis of real user feedback.
The Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack is the best dummy for babies with colic due to its lightweight, single-piece silicone design that minimises air intake. Colicky infants often swallow air while sucking, so a soother with a flat teat and good ventilation can help reduce discomfort. The Comfort Soother weighs just 0.013 kg and features a flat teat, which supports natural sucking and reduces the risk of trapped air. It is also BPA free and steriliser safe, making it suitable for frequent use.
Looking at the specs, the Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack is made from medical-grade silicone and designed for newborns from birth. The single-piece construction eliminates joints where bacteria can hide, and the absence of a clip attachment means fewer parts to clean. It comes in pink or green and is easy to sterilise, which is crucial for babies prone to digestive issues. The flat teat shape is gentle on developing mouths and helps maintain a good latch.
Other options include the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 (£6.28), which also features a symmetrical silicone teat and a storage box, and the Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush (£6.99), offering a variety of teat shapes but not recommended for colic due to the lack of steriliser safety for latex/rubber parts. The Tommee Tippee UltraLight Stayput Soothers 6-18m Pack of 4 (£8.99) is another silicone alternative, but its size and weight are better suited for older babies.
For babies with colic, our pick is the Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack. Its lightweight, hygienic design and flat teat make it the most suitable option for reducing air intake and soothing unsettled tummies.
Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 vs Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ 2-pack
Between the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 and the Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ 2-pack, the Original Pure Silicone is better for younger babies, while the Perfect Soother is designed for older infants and toddlers. The main difference is the age suitability and teat thickness, which affects comfort and oral development. Both are made from silicone and are BPA free, but their designs cater to different stages.
The Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother is suitable for babies aged 2-6 months, weighs 0.016 kg per soother, and features a symmetrical teat with four ventilation holes. It comes with a storage box and is steriliser safe. The Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ is intended for children 12 months and older, weighs 0.018 kg, and has a thinner orthodontic teat (2.28 mm) to support healthy dental development. Both offer limited colour options, but the Perfect Soother includes blue, pink, and grey.
Price-wise, the Original Pure Silicone Soother costs £6.28 for a pack of two, while the Perfect Soother 12m+ is slightly cheaper at £5.41 for two. If you are shopping for a newborn, the Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack (£11.30) is another option to consider, particularly for premature or very young infants. For parents looking for variety, the Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush (£6.99) offers different teat materials and shapes, but is less suitable for toddlers.
For babies under 6 months, the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother is the clear winner. For toddlers and older infants, the Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ is the better choice due to its orthodontic design and age-appropriate features.
What is the best dummy for eczema-prone babies?
The Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 is the best dummy for eczema-prone babies thanks to its medical-grade silicone and smooth, joint-free design. Babies with sensitive skin need a soother that minimises irritation and is easy to keep clean. The Mam Original Pure Silicone offers a symmetrical teat and four ventilation holes, which help reduce moisture build-up around the mouth—a common trigger for eczema flare-ups.
In terms of specs, this soother is made entirely from medical-grade silicone, weighs 0.016 kg, and is BPA free. The symmetrical teat and ventilation holes encourage airflow, while the included storage box keeps the dummy hygienic between uses. It is steriliser safe, which is essential for babies with skin sensitivities, as regular sterilisation helps prevent bacterial growth.
Other contenders include the Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack (£11.30), which is also made from silicone and features a single-piece design, and the Tommee Tippee UltraLight Stayput Soothers 6-18m Pack of 4, which are silicone but heavier and larger. The Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush (£6.99) includes latex and natural rubber options, which may not be ideal for eczema-prone babies due to potential allergens.
For babies with eczema, we recommend the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2. Its smooth silicone surface and well-ventilated shield help keep delicate skin dry and comfortable.
Is the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 worth £6.28?
Yes, the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 is worth £6.28 for parents seeking a hygienic, durable, and baby-friendly dummy. The medical-grade silicone construction and symmetrical teat make it suitable for most infants, while the included storage box adds value for families on the go. Its lightweight design (0.016 kg per soother) and four ventilation holes help reduce skin irritation and keep the dummy comfortable during longer use.
According to the spec sheet, this soother is BPA free, steriliser safe, and designed for babies aged 2-6 months. The symmetrical teat shape supports natural sucking, and the limited colour options keep things simple. The storage box is a practical addition for travel or keeping spares clean. The soother is easy to sterilise, which is essential for maintaining hygiene with frequent use.
Comparing prices, the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother is mid-range at £6.28 for two. The Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack is pricier at £11.30, while the Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ 2-pack is more affordable at £5.41 but intended for older babies. The Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush (£6.99) offers more variety but lacks steriliser safety for all components.
For its combination of safety, comfort, and value, the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 is a sound investment for parents looking for a reliable everyday dummy.
Common mistakes when buying baby dummy
1
Choosing the wrong size for your baby's age
Many parents pick a dummy based on looks or price, but age range matters. For example, the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother is designed for 2-6 months, while the Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ is for older babies. Using the wrong size can affect comfort and oral development. Always check the recommended age range on the packaging before buying.
2
Overlooking steriliser safety
Not all dummies can be sterilised the same way. The Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush includes latex and natural rubber, which are not microwave steriliser safe. In contrast, Mam silicone dummies like the Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack can be sterilised easily. Check the material and care instructions to avoid damaging the dummy or risking hygiene.
3
Ignoring dummy material allergies
Some babies react to latex or rubber, leading to rashes or discomfort. The Bibs Try-It Collection offers latex and natural rubber options, but silicone dummies like the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother are hypoallergenic and safer for sensitive skin. If your baby has eczema or allergies, opt for medical-grade silicone models.
4
Not considering nighttime features
Parents often forget to look for glow-in-the-dark dummies for night feeds. The Mam night soother blue 2-6m 2pk glows, making it easier to find in the dark. Standard dummies like the Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack do not have this feature, which can lead to lost dummies and disrupted sleep.
Frequently asked questions about baby dummy
Are Bibs Baby Try-It Collection dummies good for teething?
+
Bibs Baby Try-It Collection dummies can help soothe teething babies, but their effectiveness depends on the teat material. The pack includes latex, natural rubber, and polypropylene dummies, each with a different feel. Latex and rubber teats are softer and more flexible, which some teething babies prefer to chew on. However, these materials are not microwave steriliser safe, so hygiene can be harder to maintain. If your baby has sensitive gums or allergies, a silicone dummy like the Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack may be a better option.
Does the Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack suit babies who reject silicone?
+
The Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack may not suit babies who reject silicone, as it is made entirely from silicone. Some infants prefer the feel of latex or natural rubber, which are softer and warmer in the mouth. If your baby refuses silicone dummies, the Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush offers a variety of materials to try. This can help you identify which teat your baby prefers without committing to a single type.
Can you sterilise Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush in the microwave?
+
No, you should not sterilise the Bibs Baby Try-It Collection 3-pack Blush in the microwave if it contains latex or natural rubber dummies. These materials can degrade or become damaged under high heat. Only the polypropylene dummy in the pack is suitable for microwave sterilisation. For parents who need easy sterilisation, a fully silicone dummy like the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 is a safer choice.
Which dummy is best for night feeds?
+
The Mam night soother blue 2-6m 2pk is the best dummy for night feeds due to its glow-in-the-dark feature. This makes it easy to locate in a dark room without turning on lights and disturbing your baby. The soother is made from silicone, weighs 0.017 kg, and is steriliser safe. The included storage box keeps it clean between uses, and the four ventilation holes help prevent skin irritation during long nights.
Are Mam dummies suitable for babies with tongue tie?
+
Mam dummies, such as the Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack, are often suitable for babies with tongue tie because of their flat or symmetrical teat shapes. These designs support natural sucking and place less strain on the tongue. The lightweight silicone construction (0.013 kg per soother) also makes it easier for babies with oral challenges to keep the dummy in their mouth. However, every baby is different, so monitor comfort and consult your health visitor if unsure.
What is the best budget-friendly newborn dummy?
+
The Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ 2-pack is the most budget-friendly option among top-rated dummies, priced at £5.41 for two. While intended for older babies, it is often available in multipacks at a lower cost per dummy. For newborns, the Mam Original Pure Silicone Soother, 2-6 Months, Pack of 2 is a good value at £6.28. Both are BPA free, steriliser safe, and made from silicone, offering reliable quality without breaking the bank.
Which dummy is best for toddlers: Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ or Tommee Tippee UltraLight Stayput Soothers?
+
For toddlers, the Mam Perfect Soother 12m+ 2-pack is the better choice due to its orthodontic design and thinner teat (2.28 mm), which supports healthy dental development. It is made from silicone, weighs 0.018 kg, and is steriliser safe. The Tommee Tippee UltraLight Stayput Soothers are also suitable, but their larger size and weight may not suit all toddlers. The Mam Perfect Soother offers more colour options and a proven track record for older babies.
Is there a dummy suitable for premature infants?
+
The Mam Comfort Soother 0+m 2-pack is suitable for premature infants, thanks to its lightweight (0.013 kg), single-piece silicone design. It is easy to sterilise and has a flat teat, which is gentle on tiny mouths. The absence of joints and clips reduces choking risks and makes cleaning straightforward. For very small or medically fragile babies, always consult your neonatal team before introducing any soother.
Other baby dummy included in the test
These models were tested but did not make the top 5
