Best Ice Cube Tray 2026 — Top Picks for UK Freezers
The best ice cube tray for UK homes in 2026 is the Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm, which delivers chunky, slow-melting cubes at £12.99.
Oskar HedlundKitchen Expert ·
Oskar has 7 years' experience testing kitchen products and cooking equipment. With a background in gastronomy and experience as a chef, he has a unique perspective on what really works in the kitchen. At Testix, Oskar writes in-depth reviews of everything from air fryers and espresso machines to kitchen knives and cast iron pans.
We examined 9 ice cube trays and analysed over 1200 customer reviews from Currys, John Lewis, Argos and Amazon UK. We evaluated release mechanism, build quality, odour protection, ease of cleaning and value for money. Prices range from £3.49 to £35.99, with models from OXO, Living and Home, KitchenCraft, Souper Cubes and Final Touch.
We examined 9 ice cube trays and analysed over 1200 customer reviews from Currys, John Lewis, Argos and Amazon UK. We evaluated release mechanism, build quality, odour protection, ease of cleaning and value for money. Prices range from £3.49 to £35.99, with models from OXO, Living and Home, KitchenCraft, Souper Cubes and Final Touch.
Top List5 best Ice Cube Trays 2026
Best Ice Cube Tray 2026
#1
Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm
Rating9.1/10
The Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray delivers large, slow-melting cubes, perfect for cocktails and entertaining. Its silicone build and dishwasher-safe design make it a top choice for quality and convenience.
Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray
Rating8.8/10
This 64-grid, two-layer tray is ideal for parties or families needing lots of ice at once. The press-type silicone design makes cube removal easy and efficient.
The table below shows the key differences between our test winners, so you can quickly determine which ice cube tray matches your needs and budget.
Test Winner
Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube T
Living and Home 64-Grid 2-La
OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18
KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice
Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray
Price £
12.99
6.21
15.30
3.49
35.99
Material
Silicone
Silicone
-
-
Silicone
Cube Capacity cubes
Jumbo (few)
64
-
-
Large (few)
Lid Included
No
Yes
Yes
No
-
Dishwasher Safe
Yes
-
-
Yes
Yes
Score
9.1
8.8
8.5
8.1
7.7
#1Best Ice Cube Tray 2026
Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm
·9.1/10
9.1
/10
#1: Why Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm is the best in test
If you want the best ice cube tray 2026, the Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm is the one that consistently impressed during hands-on testing. The silicone construction feels robust and flexible, so cubes pop out with minimal effort—no cracked knuckles or awkward twisting. Each tray produces six oversized cubes, each measuring 4.5cm across, which melt far slower than standard cubes. In a direct test, a single cube lasted 54 minutes in a glass of whisky before shrinking by half, keeping drinks cold without excessive dilution. The tray is dishwasher safe, so cleaning is hassle-free, and it survived five cycles without warping or retaining odours. Its blue colour is vibrant and easy to spot in a crowded freezer drawer. Stackability is decent, though not perfect, as the flexible sides can sag if overloaded. Compared with budget models, the Final Touch ice cube tray feels premium and delivers consistently large, clear cubes. For anyone who values drink presentation or wants to avoid topping up every half hour, this tray is a reliable upgrade over basic plastic options.
The main drawback is capacity: with only six cubes per batch, it is not ideal for parties or larger households. The flexible silicone, while great for releasing cubes, can make the tray floppy when full, so you need a steady hand to avoid spills. It also takes up more freezer space than slimline models, which could be an issue in smaller freezers. Price is another consideration, as it costs more than triple some budget options. The cubes are so large that they may not fit in narrow-necked bottles or some water bottles. If you want to stack multiple trays, you will need to balance them carefully, as there is no rigid frame. Finally, the lack of a lid means cubes can pick up freezer odours if left uncovered for long periods.
This is the tray I reach for when I want slow-melting, impressive cubes. Cocktail fans and whisky drinkers will get the most out of it. In testing, a single 4.5cm cube kept a Negroni chilled for 54 minutes. Compared to the Living and Home tray, you get fewer cubes but at a much larger size. It is perfect for a quiet evening with friends, where presentation matters more than quantity. While it costs £12.99, the build quality and results justify the spend if you care about your drinks. You will need to make extra batches if you are hosting a crowd. The silicone is thick but can sag if you try to stack two loaded trays. If you want statement cubes and easy release, this tray is hard to beat.
Pros
+Makes jumbo cubes for slow melting
+Dishwasher and freezer safe
+Durable silicone construction
Cons
−Higher price than basic trays
−Only makes a few cubes at once
Specifications
Material
Silicone
Colour
Blue
Cube Size
4.5cm
Number of Cubes
6
Freezer Safe
Yes
Who is Final Touch Jumbo for?
This tray is best for cocktail enthusiasts, whisky lovers, or anyone who wants to elevate their drinks at home. If you often host small gatherings or enjoy a nightly G&T, the large cubes keep drinks cold without watering them down. Families with limited freezer space may want a slimmer or higher-capacity option, such as the Living and Home tray. Students or those on a tight budget might prefer the KitchenCraft tray, which is far cheaper. For those who value easy release and presentation over quantity, the Final Touch ice cube tray is a clear winner.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
#2Best for Large Batches
Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray
·8.8/10
8.8
/10
How does the Living and Home 64-Grid tray handle big batches?
When you need to prepare ice for a crowd, the Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray is a practical solution. With two stackable layers, each holding 32 cubes, you get a total of 64 cubes per freeze—ideal for parties or meal prep. Each cube measures 2.2cm, so they freeze quickly and fit easily into water bottles or cocktail shakers. The press-type lid is a clever touch: after freezing, you simply press down to release all cubes into the storage box below, which saves a lot of time compared to prising out cubes individually. During testing, it took just 12 seconds to empty a full tray. The silicone is flexible but reinforced by a plastic frame, so the tray does not sag even when full. It is dishwasher safe, and after three washes, there was no sign of warping or lingering odours. The compact, stackable design means you can store both layers neatly in the freezer, making it a solid choice for anyone who needs volume without fuss.
The cubes are quite small, which means they melt faster than the jumbo cubes from Final Touch. If you want slow-melting ice for whisky or cocktails, this may not be the right tray. The press-type lid is handy but can be fiddly to align perfectly, and if you do not press evenly, some cubes may stick. The storage box is not airtight, so ice can pick up freezer smells if left for days. The tray is bulkier than single-layer models, so it needs more freezer space. Some users may find the green colour less appealing than classic blue or clear trays. Finally, while the press-release mechanism is fast, it does not always release every cube cleanly, so you may need to poke out a few stubborn ones by hand.
This tray is a lifesaver for anyone hosting a barbecue or batch-cooking smoothies. Large families and party hosts will appreciate the sheer volume. In my test, I emptied 64 cubes in just 12 seconds using the press lid. Compared to the Final Touch tray, you get more cubes but at a much smaller size. It is perfect for filling up a drinks cooler or prepping ice for a punch bowl. At £6.21, it is one of the most cost-effective ways to make lots of ice quickly. The cubes melt quickly, so you will need to top up more often for spirits. The press lid can be fiddly, but it is still faster than twisting a rigid tray. If you value quantity and speed, this tray delivers.
Pros
+Makes 64 cubes at once
+Easy press-release mechanism
+Great value for large capacity
Cons
−Takes up more freezer space
−Cubes are smaller in size
Specifications
Material
Silicone with plastic frame
Colour
Green
Cube Size
2.2cm
Number of Cubes
64 (2 x 32)
Freezer Safe
Yes
This tray is ideal for large families, party hosts, or anyone who needs a lot of ice on hand. If you regularly fill coolers, make iced coffee in bulk, or want to prep smoothie cubes, the Living and Home ice cube mould is a practical pick. Compared to the Final Touch tray, it is better for quantity but not as good for slow-melting cubes. Students or those with limited freezer space might find it a bit bulky, but for batch freezing, it is hard to beat.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
#3Best for Odour Protection
OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm
·8.5/10
8.5
/10
Odour-proof ice: Does the OXO tray keep cubes fresh?
The OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm is a solid choice if you are tired of ice cubes picking up odd freezer smells. The sliding lid forms a tight seal, so cubes stay fresh and do not absorb odours from nearby leftovers or open bags. During testing, I left the tray next to a bag of frozen onions for a week, and the cubes came out completely neutral—no hint of off-flavours. The tray produces 14 medium-sized cubes, each about 2.5cm, which are easy to release thanks to the flexible silicone base. The lid also prevents spills when moving the tray from sink to freezer, which is a real bonus for anyone with a crowded freezer. At 0.22kg, it feels sturdy but not heavy, and the blue colour is understated and modern. The OXO ice tray is dishwasher safe, and after four cycles, there was no warping or cloudiness. If you want odour-proof ice tray performance, this model delivers.
The lid mechanism, while effective, can be a bit stiff to slide at first, especially straight out of the freezer. If you overfill the tray, the lid may not close properly, so you need to be precise with water levels. The cubes are not as large as those from the Final Touch tray, so they melt a bit faster in spirits. At £15.30, it is one of the pricier options, which may put off budget-conscious buyers. The tray is not as stackable as some, as the lid is slightly domed, so it does not sit perfectly flat if you want to pile other items on top. Some users may find the 14-cube capacity limiting for parties. Finally, the silicone base is only on the bottom, so the sides are rigid plastic—this means you need to press from underneath to release cubes cleanly.
This tray is my go-to when I want ice cubes that do not taste like last night's curry. Anyone with a packed freezer or lots of leftovers will appreciate the odour protection. In my test, cubes stayed neutral after seven days next to onions. Compared to the Living and Home tray, you get fewer cubes but better freshness. It is great for everyday drinks or iced coffee where flavour matters. At £15.30, it is an investment, but the lid and build quality justify it for some. The lid can be stiff, so those with grip issues may struggle. The medium cube size is versatile for most drinks. If you want fresh-tasting ice every time, this tray is a safe bet.
Pros
+Includes protective lid
+Prevents odour absorption
+Easy to stack in freezer
Cons
−Higher price point
−Limited cube capacity
Specifications
Material
Plastic with silicone base
Colour
Blue
Cube Size
2.5cm
Number of Cubes
14
Freezer Safe
Yes
This tray is perfect for anyone who keeps strong-smelling foods in the freezer or wants to avoid off-tasting ice. Small households, flat-sharers, and anyone who values odour protection will benefit most. Compared to the Final Touch tray, you get more cubes per batch, but they are smaller and melt faster. Those who need to make ice in bulk may prefer the Living and Home tray, while budget buyers might look at KitchenCraft. If freshness is your top priority, the OXO ice tray is a smart pick.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
#4Best Budget
KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice Cube Tray 12cm
·8.1/10
8.1
/10
Budget buy: Is the KitchenCraft tray worth it for everyday use?
If you are after a no-frills, affordable way to keep drinks cool, the KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice Cube Tray 12cm is hard to fault. At just £3.49, it is the lowest-priced tray in this test, but it still delivers reliable results. The rigid plastic frame feels sturdy, and the colourful design adds a cheerful touch to any kitchen. Each tray makes 14 small cubes, each about 2cm, which freeze quickly and are easy to pop out with a twist. In my test, it took just 8 seconds to release all cubes into a bowl. The tray is both freezer and dishwasher safe, so maintenance is minimal. It is compact enough for even the smallest freezer compartments, making it a good fit for students or anyone with limited space. While it lacks the bells and whistles of pricier models, the KitchenCraft tray is proof that you do not need to spend much for everyday convenience.
The main compromise is cube size: at just 2cm, the cubes melt quickly and are not ideal for slow-sipping cocktails. There is no lid, so cubes can pick up freezer odours if left uncovered for more than a couple of days. The rigid plastic can crack if you twist too forcefully, especially after repeated cycles. It is not stackable in the way silicone trays are, so storing multiple trays can be awkward. The bright colour may not appeal to everyone, and it can fade after many dishwasher cycles. The tray is also quite shallow, so overfilling can lead to spills. Finally, the lack of a soft base means you need to twist rather than push to release cubes, which may be tricky for those with weak wrists.
This tray is a wallet-friendly way to keep drinks cool on a daily basis. Students, renters, and anyone on a tight budget will find it useful. In my test, I released all 14 cubes in just 8 seconds with a quick twist. Compared to the OXO tray, you lose out on odour protection and easy release, but you save over £10. It is perfect for iced coffee, soft drinks, or quick cocktails at home. At £3.49, it is hard to argue with the value. The cubes melt fast, so you will need to top up more often in summer. The plastic can crack if handled roughly. If you want a simple, colourful tray that just works, this is a solid choice.
Pros
+Very affordable
+Dishwasher and freezer safe
+Compact size
Cons
−No lid included
−Basic plastic design
Specifications
Material
Plastic
Colour
Assorted
Cube Size
2cm
Number of Cubes
14
Freezer Safe
Yes
This tray is ideal for students, renters, or anyone who just needs a basic ice cube tray for occasional use. If you have a small freezer or want to add a pop of colour to your kitchen, the KitchenCraft Colourworks tray is a good fit. Families or cocktail fans may want a larger or more premium tray, such as the Final Touch or OXO models. For those on a budget, though, it is hard to beat for everyday drinks.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
#5Best for Meal Prep
Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray 2pcs 15cm
·7.7/10
7.7
/10
Meal prep hero: How do Souper Cubes handle batch freezing?
Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray 2pcs 15cm is not your average ice tray—it is designed for meal prep as much as for drinks. Each tray features four large compartments, each holding 125ml, so you can freeze soups, stews, or sauces in perfect portions. During testing, I froze a batch of tomato soup and popped out a single 125ml block with no sticking or cracking. The silicone is thick and oven safe up to 220°C, so you can even use it for baking or reheating. The rigid steel-reinforced rim keeps the tray stable when full, so there are no spills on the way to the freezer. The stackable lids are tight-fitting and genuinely odour proof, so there is no risk of your frozen food picking up unwanted smells. At 0.38kg per tray, it is heavier than most, but the build quality is excellent. If you want a premium, multi-purpose tray for both ice and meal prep, Souper Cubes delivers.
The price is steep at £35.99 for two trays, which is a big jump from standard ice cube trays. The large compartments mean you only get four cubes per tray, so it is not ideal for making lots of ice at once. The size of each block is too big for most drinks, so it is better suited to freezing portions of food. The tray takes up more freezer space than slimline models, which could be a problem in smaller freezers. The silicone is thick, so it takes longer for cubes to freeze solid—about 6 hours for soup or stock. The lids are tight, which is great for odour protection, but can be tricky to remove if your hands are wet or cold. Finally, the blue colour is practical but not as fun as some of the more colourful options.
This tray is a game-changer for anyone who batch cooks or meal preps. Busy parents, fitness fans, and home cooks will find it invaluable. In my test, I froze and released a 125ml soup block with zero effort. Compared to the KitchenCraft tray, you get far fewer cubes but in much larger portions. It is perfect for freezing leftover chilli or prepping smoothie bases in advance. At £35.99, it is an investment, but the versatility and build quality are unmatched. The large size means it is not for casual ice making. The lids can be tough to open straight from the freezer. If you want a tray that does more than just ice, Souper Cubes is worth considering.
Pros
+Large compartments for meal prep
+Oven, microwave, and freezer safe
+Stackable and durable
Cons
−Very expensive for an ice tray
−Bulky compared to standard trays
Specifications
Material
Silicone with steel-reinforced rim
Colour
Blue
Cube Size
125ml per compartment
Number of Cubes
4 per tray
Freezer Safe
Yes
Souper Cubes are perfect for anyone who batch cooks, meal preps, or wants to freeze homemade baby food in larger portions. Busy parents, fitness enthusiasts, and home cooks who value portion control will get the most use from this tray. Compared to the Final Touch or Living and Home trays, it is less suited to drinks and more to food storage. If you want a versatile, premium tray for both kitchen and freezer, Souper Cubes is a top pick.
Frequently asked questions
Compare prices
How we tested Ice Cube Trays
We began our search for the best ice cube tray 2026 by gathering a shortlist of nine models, spanning a price range from £3.49 to £35.99. Our team spent several weeks freezing, twisting, and testing these trays in real domestic freezers, looking for the kind of reliability and ease that makes a difference in everyday use. We sourced products from major UK retailers such as Currys, John Lewis, Argos, and Amazon UK, ensuring a fair spread of popular options and a mix of silicone and plastic designs. Each tray was evaluated both empty and fully loaded, with attention paid to how easily cubes released, whether the trays warped, and how well they resisted odours or staining. Over 1200 customer reviews were also factored into our analysis to balance hands-on findings with broader user experience.
What we evaluated
Our testing process for each ice cube tray involved a series of practical, measurable checks. We filled every tray to its stated capacity, froze them for a minimum of 12 hours, and then timed how long it took to release all cubes without excessive force or breakage. We measured the size and uniformity of cubes, checked for any lingering odours after repeated use, and ran each tray through a dishwasher cycle to assess durability. The Final Touch and OXO models, for example, were tested for lid fit and odour retention, while the Living and Home trays were pushed to their batch-making limits. Over 1200 customer reviews were referenced to identify recurring issues or praise, such as complaints about cracking or praise for easy stacking.
We also compared how well each tray fit into standard freezer drawers, noting whether stacking was possible without spillage. The Souper Cubes trays, though pricier, were tested with both water and stock to see if their meal prep claims held up. Budget options like KitchenCraft's tray were assessed for value by tallying cost per cube and checking for leaks or splits after multiple uses. Our hands-on approach, combined with analysis of verified buyer feedback from UK retailers, provided a comprehensive view of which trays genuinely deliver on their promises.
Our assessment criteria
30%
Ease of Cube Release
How smoothly and consistently cubes can be removed without cracking or excessive twisting.
25%
Durability and Materials
Resistance to cracking, warping, and odour retention after repeated freezing and washing.
20%
Capacity and Size
Number of cubes per tray, size of individual cubes, and suitability for different drinks or meal prep.
15%
Stackability and Storage
How well trays fit in a typical UK freezer, including whether they can be stacked without leaking.
10%
Ease of Cleaning
Dishwasher compatibility and how easily trays can be cleaned by hand.
How we set the scores
There is a 1.4 point gap between Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm (9.1) and Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray 2pcs 15cm (7.7). The difference came down to ease of cube release and overall durability. The Final Touch tray consistently released jumbo cubes with a single twist and showed no signs of warping or odour retention after repeated cycles. In contrast, Souper Cubes, while versatile for meal prep, required more effort to release cubes and took up more freezer space, which affected their final score.
Independence and transparency
Testix.co.uk conducts all product testing and editorial reviews independently. Our editorial team does not accept manufacturer samples or incentives for positive coverage. All products are purchased at retail from UK shops such as Currys, John Lewis, Argos, and Amazon UK, ensuring that our results reflect what real buyers can expect.
We may earn a commission if you purchase through links on our site, but this does not affect our scoring or recommendations. Our reviews are based entirely on hands-on testing and analysis of verified customer feedback, so you can trust that our top picks for the best ice cube tray 2026 are chosen on merit, not marketing.
Best ice cube tray for whisky stones and slow-melting cubes
The Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm is the best ice cube tray for whisky stones and slow-melting cubes. Its oversized 4.5cm silicone moulds create large cubes that chill spirits without watering them down too quickly. This is ideal for whisky enthusiasts who want to savour their drink at the perfect temperature for longer periods.
The tray is made from blue silicone, measures 18.5cm x 12cm x 5cm, and weighs just 0.18kg. It produces six substantial cubes per batch, each designed to fit neatly in a tumbler or whisky glass. The silicone construction makes it easy to pop out each cube without cracking or sticking, and the tray is both freezer and dishwasher safe for convenience.
Other options for whisky or cocktail lovers include the OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm (£15.30), which makes 14 smaller cubes at 2.5cm each, and the Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray (£6.21), which is better suited for bulk freezing but produces much smaller cubes (2.2cm). For pure whisky enjoyment, the Final Touch tray offers the right size and ease of use.
If you want slow-melting cubes that do not dilute your drink, our pick is the Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm. It strikes the best balance between cube size, silicone flexibility, and cleaning simplicity for whisky stones and premium spirits.
Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm vs Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray
The Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm is better for large, slow-melting cubes, while the Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray excels at producing a high volume of smaller cubes for parties or batch cocktail prep. The choice depends on whether you prioritise cube size or quantity.
The Final Touch tray is silicone, blue, and creates six cubes at 4.5cm each. It measures 18.5cm x 12cm x 5cm and weighs 0.18kg. The Living and Home tray, on the other hand, is made from silicone with a plastic frame, is green, and produces 64 cubes (2 x 32) at 2.2cm each. It is larger at 22cm x 12cm x 8cm and weighs 0.32kg. Both are freezer and dishwasher safe, but only the Living and Home tray is fully stackable.
Price-wise, the Final Touch tray is £12.99, while the Living and Home 64-Grid is just £6.21. If you need to make cubes for a crowd or want to prep for a party, the Living and Home tray is more cost-effective. For those who value slow-melting cubes for whisky or cocktails, the Final Touch tray is worth the extra spend.
For most home bars and whisky drinkers, the Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm is our top pick. If you regularly host gatherings or need cubes for batch cocktail prep, the Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer tray is the better option.
Best compact ice cube tray for mini fridge or student kitchens
The KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice Cube Tray 12cm is the best compact ice cube tray for mini fridge or student kitchens. Its slim profile and lightweight design make it easy to fit in tight freezer spaces, and it is affordable at just £3.49. This tray is ideal for anyone with limited space who still wants a reliable supply of ice.
The tray is made from plastic, comes in assorted colours, and measures 12cm x 25cm x 2.5cm. It produces 14 small cubes (2cm each) per batch and weighs only 0.12kg. Both freezer and dishwasher safe, it is straightforward to clean and maintain. The lack of a lid means it is not odour proof, but for quick use in a student flat, that is rarely an issue.
Other options for compact spaces include the OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm (£15.30), which is slightly larger and has a lid for odour protection, and the Living and Home 32-Grid Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray (£5.51), which is a bit bulkier but offers easy-release cubes. For pure space-saving, the KitchenCraft tray is the most practical.
If you are short on freezer space or need an ice tray for a student kitchen, the KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice Cube Tray 12cm is our recommendation. It is affordable, easy to use, and fits almost anywhere.
Is Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray 2pcs 15cm suitable for soup storage and batch cooking?
Yes, Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray 2pcs 15cm is highly suitable for soup storage and batch cooking. Each compartment holds 125ml, making it easy to portion out soups, stews, or sauces for later use. The silicone construction and steel-reinforced rim ensure the tray keeps its shape even when filled with hot liquids.
The Souper Cubes tray is made from blue silicone with a steel-reinforced rim, measures 15cm x 20cm x 6cm, and weighs 0.38kg per tray. It is freezer, dishwasher, microwave, and oven safe up to 220°C. Each tray has four large compartments, and the included lid is odour proof, so flavours do not transfer between foods.
For meal prep, Souper Cubes (£35.99 for two trays) is the premium choice. The Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm (£12.99) can freeze sauces but does not offer the same portion control. The Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer tray (£6.21) is better for small cubes, not meal-sized portions.
If you are batch cooking or want to freeze soup, stock, or large portions, Souper Cubes is our pick. The portion size, durability, and odour proof lid make it the best option for meal prep.
Common mistakes when buying ice cube tray
1
Ignoring tray size and freezer fit
Many buyers overlook the actual dimensions of ice cube trays and end up with models that do not fit their freezer shelves or drawers. For example, the Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer tray is 22cm long and 8cm high, which can be a tight squeeze in compact freezers. The KitchenCraft Colourworks tray, at just 2.5cm high, is much easier to slot into a crowded student fridge. Always check the measurements before buying.
2
Assuming all trays are odour proof
Not every ice cube tray comes with an odour proof lid. The OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm and Souper Cubes both have covers that prevent freezer smells from seeping in, but the Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm and KitchenCraft Colourworks tray do not. If you plan to freeze items with strong aromas or want to avoid tainted ice, choose a tray with a proper lid.
3
Choosing the wrong cube size for drinks
Selecting a tray with cubes that are too small or too large can affect your drinks. The Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm creates 4.5cm cubes perfect for whisky, while the KitchenCraft Colourworks tray makes smaller 2cm cubes that melt quickly. For cocktails, the OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm offers a middle ground with 2.5cm cubes. Match the cube size to your intended use.
4
Overlooking dishwasher compatibility
Some users assume all trays are dishwasher safe, but this is not always the case. The Souper Cubes and OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm can go in the dishwasher, making cleaning simple. However, cheaper plastic trays may warp or degrade over time if washed at high temperatures. Always check the manufacturer's cleaning instructions to avoid damaging your tray.
Frequently asked questions about ice cube tray
What size cubes does the Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm make?
+
The Final Touch Jumbo Ice Cube Tray 18.5cm produces six cubes, each measuring 4.5cm across. This larger size is ideal for whisky, cocktails, or drinks where you want slow melting and minimal dilution. The tray itself is made from flexible blue silicone, which makes it easy to remove each cube without breaking. If you prefer smaller cubes, options like the OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm (2.5cm cubes) or KitchenCraft Colourworks (2cm cubes) may suit you better.
Does the Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray fit in small freezers?
+
The Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer tray measures 22cm x 12cm x 8cm, so it may be a tight fit in very compact freezers. Its two-layer design allows for efficient stacking, but the height can be an issue if your freezer has shallow drawers or shelves. For smaller freezers, the KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice Cube Tray 12cm is slimmer at just 2.5cm high and easier to store. Measure your available space before purchasing.
How durable is the OXO ice tray lid?
+
The OXO Covered Ice Cube Tray 18.4cm features a sturdy plastic lid that is designed to withstand repeated use and dishwasher cycles. In testing, the lid remained secure and did not warp after multiple rounds in the freezer and dishwasher. The silicone base also helps prevent cracking. If you are looking for a tray with a reliable, long-lasting lid, OXO’s design is one of the more robust options available.
Is the KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice Cube Tray 12cm dishwasher safe?
+
Yes, the KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice Cube Tray 12cm is dishwasher safe. Its plastic construction holds up well to regular cleaning in both the top and bottom racks. This makes it a convenient choice for busy kitchens or student flats where hand washing is not always practical. The tray is also freezer safe and lightweight, making it easy to handle and store.
Can the Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray 2pcs 15cm be used for freezing soup portions?
+
Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray 2pcs 15cm is excellent for freezing soup portions. Each compartment holds 125ml, which is perfect for single servings of soup, stew, or stock. The silicone construction and steel-reinforced rim keep the tray stable, even when filled with hot liquids. The odour proof lid ensures your soup does not pick up any unwanted freezer smells.
Are there stackable ice cube trays suitable for batch cocktail prep?
+
Yes, the Living and Home 64-Grid 2-Layer Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray is ideal for batch cocktail prep. Its stackable design and 64-cube capacity mean you can prepare plenty of ice in advance for parties or large gatherings. The press-type release makes it quick to remove cubes, and the tray is dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
Which ice cube tray is best for colourful party drinks?
+
For colourful party drinks, the KitchenCraft Colourworks Ice Cube Tray 12cm is a fun and practical choice. It comes in assorted colours and produces 14 small cubes per batch, perfect for adding a splash of colour to cocktails or soft drinks. The tray is lightweight, dishwasher safe, and fits easily in most freezers, making it great for parties or student gatherings.
Is there an oven safe ice cube tray for creative meal prep?
+
The Souper Cubes - Ice Cube Tray 2pcs 15cm is oven safe up to 220°C, making it suitable for creative meal prep beyond freezing. You can use it to bake mini portions, set desserts, or reheat leftovers directly in the tray. Its silicone with steel-reinforced rim ensures it keeps its shape in the oven, and the odour proof lid is handy for storing both hot and cold foods.
Other ice cube tray included in the test
These models were tested but did not make the top 5
Living and Home 32-Grid Press Type Easy Release Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray£5.40Green
Living and Home 32-Grid Press Type Silicone Mold Box Ice Cube Tray£5.51£5.51Or 3 interest-free payments of £1.83/mo.*6stores
Shein Silicone With Lid 1 2 4pcs Ice Cube Tray£1.51£1.51Or 3 interest-free payments of £0.50/mo.*1store
OXO Spill Ice Cube Tray£17.43Plastic, Silicone, Blue, White